The Season 1 finale of this Beastly show left us with many questions, like: Who took Vincent? Who is Catherine’s real dad? And that’s just the tip of the iceberg. The stars spoke at Comic-Con a little bit about what’s to come: “They’re pulled apart and we’re going to discover what Vincent has been turned into, I guess,” Ryan says. “And it’s sort of like, ‘Who am I?'” Is he beast, or is he man? He has to sort of rediscover that and navigate a new relationship with Catherine. … We were pushed together very quickly in season one — a lot because the fans were sort of, you know, chanting for it — so we gave it to them, but now, for objectivity, we need to regroup again.”

“Well, they need to earn it,” Kreuk adds about their characters. “You don’t know that it’s really love until there’s been some difficulty, and that’s going to be the season. Jay mentioned the ‘Who am I?’ thing and that’s kind of the theme of our entire season for all of the characters. It’s really discovering who they are on their own. We’ll surely get some answers, along with more questions, during Season 2, set to air Mondays on The CW starting 10/7. Check local listings for times.