Hanna’s Creepiest Moment
During the Season 2 finale, “unmAsked,” Hanna takes a Psycho-esque shower at the creepy Lost Woods resort, with a freaky silhouette of A lurking in the background.
Emily’s Creepiest Moment
Emily is not sure what to make of Toby when he first returns, but agrees to go with him to Homecoming anyway (“There’s No Place Like Homecoming”). Toby gets defensive when Emily asks about his tattoo, which sends Emily into a panic and Toby chasing after her.
Aria’s Creepiest Moment
During the famous train ride on Season 3’s Halloween episode (“This is a Dark Ride”), Aria is drugged by A, bound, gagged, and imprisoned in a crate with Garrett’s dead body. Anyone who experiences claustrophobia will remember this moment and shudder.
Spencer’s Creepiest Moment
The electrifying Season 1 finale featured another Hitchcock moment when Ian chased Spencer up the church tower a la Vertigo. This is the kind of pulse-pounding terror that has always kept us coming back for more.
Don’t miss the Pretty Little Liars