Fall is here, and there’s never a better time for a good old YA romance in the form of a Nicholas Sparks adaptation. With The Best of Me now in theaters, we wanted to check in and see if The Notebook still sets the standard as everyone’s favorite Sparks entry. Cast your vote below!

A Walk to Remember

The first super successful Nicholas Sparks book-to-film starred Shane West and Mandy Moore (rumored to be joining the cast of Red Band Society after a mini acting hiatus). The movie feels warm and cozy and classically American, ripe for the rewatching!

The Notebook

The one and only. Rachel McAdams and Ryan Gosling make us fall in love and totally break our hearts in this now classic heartstring-tugger and tearjerker, one that has been copied many times over.

The Last Song

MIley Cyrus and Liam Hemsworth fell in love while filming this movie, and even though their union wasn’t meant to be, you can watch them court each other in this soft and musical Sparks adaptation co-starring Greg Kinnear.

The Lucky One

Zac Efron and Nicholas Sparks is a surefire combination, and 2012’s The Lucky One was the result of their team up. The movie involves life, death, love, war and everything in between. What’s not to like?

Dear John

Another war-tinged adaptation, hotties Channing Tatum and Amanda Seyfried play new star-crossed lovers up against a tour of duty, staggering distances and lots more.